Tesla, one of the largest technology companies in the world, recently launched the first prototype of the highly anticipated humanoid robot Optimus. showed it live. The owner of the company, Elon Musk, said that Optimus is not ready yet, but the coming It will be on the market in 3-5 years explained.

After Tesla’s presentation, many world-renowned robotics experts and professors made comments about Optimus. They all made a point “Not so impressive”.

“What is the difference with Asimo?”

Professor of robotics at Florida State University, who continues to make important statements about robots. Christian Hubickic, in a statement on his Twitter account, said it was astonishing that the US tech giant could design a robot in such a short time. But the way the Optimus runs and moves is the same as the one Honda introduced in 2000. Similar to Asimo He claimed. While this system, known as Zero Moment Point, has not been confirmed to be used in Optimus, their movement patterns are really similar.

Hubicki also states that no information was given in the presentation about how many times the robot fell to the ground. Professor of Robotics, Manufactured on Earth that every robot rarely falls to the ground and data on how often a robot that has announced to work at the factory crashes. that it is vital stated. Hubicki said in a statement:While what the robot can do is amazing, it won’t be revolutionary technology by 2022” he said.

“A bold presentation but far from innovation”

Will Jackson, founder of Engineering Arts, said the introduction of a ready-made version of Optimus took guts, but that both the introduction and the robot were “successful”.outdated and old-fashionedHe claimed. This robot, which is quite similar to Asimo, attracted attention for a while for its interior design, movements and abilities. The only reason it looks more aesthetically pleasing than it is is because some of the parts used in robots today are smaller. Jackson also criticized the robot’s most notable part, the hands.

According to Jackson, although the robot’s “hands” look like human hands, in reality they are… it really can’t move like a hand. With the logic of the clamp, this equipment that only serves to squeeze the pleasures It is very difficult to grasp like a real human hand. states. Jackson also said:Elon Musk introduces the robots he will control in his factories, and the public applauds a robot whose sole function in the future is to carry pipes?” by saying that the robot is only used in the factory. it’s stupid expressed.

“Features added for convenience”

Cynthia Yeung, the production chief of robotics company Plus One, was among those who shared her criticism of Optimus. According to Yeung, although Tesla has produced a successful robot in a short time, this robot will be in the future, It won’t be much different than it is now.

Yeung said in a statement:Tesla’s robotics engineer Felix talks about the robot that walks. Yes, walking function is important, but Are you adding other features just for the sake of it or to solve problems?” by saying that systems such as walking, hands, viewing angle, object detection added to Optimus thought it would have no function in real life. explained.

The famed engineer also argued that Tesla’s preference for the 5-finger system was a mistake. Yeung stated that many robot companies prefer systems with 2 or 3 fingers or suction cups in their first robots. would create problems rather than functionality without improved connection angles. stated.

In addition to Cynthia Yeung’s criticisms, Musk said that instead of presenting the robot, he also mentioned the team behind the robot, highlighting the main heroes of the project, and that the actuators and simulators created by the team were once revolutionary. could be. Elon Musk and Optimus congratulated his team.

To summarize, many robotics engineers, Tesla’s humanoid robot Although Optimus is a nice project, it is far from innovative. is thinking. So what do you think of Optimus?