A apple appealed the decision of the court Federal Regional Court from 1st region What upheld the company’s ban on selling the iPhone without a charger. The ban began in September 2022 following a decision by the Ministry of Justice, which also determined the payment of a fine of 12 million reais.

The company said the decision to stop selling the mobile phone charger was made to reduce carbon emissions, but the National Secretariat for Consumer Protection (Senacom) understands that the charger is necessary for the device to function and therefore should be sold with it.

Judge Daniele Maranhao denied Apple’s request to suspend the obligation to sell the two products together. The case will now be referred to the class of the Federal District Court for the 1st Circuit for a ruling.

The Defense General of the Union (AGU) alleges that Apple continued to sell iPhones without chargers even after the ruling, being fined by prosecutors in São Paulo, Fortaleza, Santa Catarina and Caldas Novas (GO). The sale of the charger separately has been criticized by consumers, who claim that the company is trying to increase its profits and may also harm the environment by improperly disposing of old chargers.

A trial date for the case has not yet been set. Apple has not commented on this feature.

controversial option

Apple’s decision to sell the iPhone without a charger has sparked controversy among consumers and regulators. The company explained the change as a way to reduce carbon emissions, arguing that many users already have chargers at home and that selling the charger separately would reduce e-waste production. However, the National Secretariat for Consumer Protection (Senacom) and the Department of Justice have realized that the charger is an essential element for the operation of the device and that selling it separately represents an abuse of practice.

The ban on selling iPhones without a charger was a measure taken by the Brazilian authorities in September 2022, and Apple has already been fined for failing to comply with this determination. The company has appealed the decision and continues to sell its products without a charger in Brazil while the case is in court. The separate sale of the charger has sparked controversy about sustainable consumption, company obligations, and consumer rights.

Mundo Conectado Deal Center: Selection of Discounts and Lowest Prices
Best deals on electronics, cell phones, TVs, soundbars, drones and more

Source: Globe

…..